#63: Layering the Pigment—The Widow’s Tax and Brotherly Bonds

Halifax Hues #2: Layering the Pigment—The Widow’s Tax and Brotherly Bonds

In my last post, I shared my "Theory in Progress": the hunch that my wife’s ancestor, Daniel Epps, was the brother of William Epps, making them both sons of the Revolutionary War veteran Moses Epps. Proving a connection in early 19th-century Virginia often requires looking at who lived next door to whom. Since I lacked a birth register entry, I turned to the Halifax County Tax Lists and Census Records to see if these men occupied the same physical and legal space.

The Faded Outlines: The 1820 Census

While the 1820 Census only lists Moses Epps as the head of household, it provides the first "sketch" of the family. The tally of young males in his home aligns perfectly with the ages of William and Daniel during that period, placing them under one roof before they set out to establish their own households.

The Silent Witness: Lucy P. Cole Epps

The breakthrough didn’t come from a man, but from a widow. To understand Lucy’s role, we first connect her to the family through her marriage to William Epps. William was a successful farmer, but he died young and intestate (without a will) in 1826. In the rigid social structure of the 1830s, a woman was rarely listed as a "Head of Household" unless she was a widow holding onto her husband's land.

The county records of William’s estate inventory act as a silent witness to their life:

• The Record: Appraisers listed specific "cash crops" on hand to settle his debts.
• The Crops: Large quantities of tobacco and corn were standard items in these Halifax inventories, representing the family’s primary wealth.
• The Protector: The executor was William Cole, likely Lucy Cole Epps’ brother, stepping in to protect her interests after William’s death.

When I looked at the 1830 Census, there she was: Lucy Epps. And she wasn't alone. Just six lines away on the same census page was Moses Epps, and a few doors down from him was Daniel Epps.

The Tax District "Cluster"

By 1832, the tax records showed a definitive "family cluster" in the same district:

• Booker Epps (suspected brother)
• Daniel Epps and Obediah Epps (suspected brother) along with their father Moses were listed side-by-side.
• Lucy Epps was listed nearby, likely managing the property William had left behind.

This wasn't just a coincidence; it was a spatial inheritance. They were farming the fragmented pieces of what had once likely been a single large Epps estate.

Theory Proven

The "Theory in Progress" is now a verified lineage. By combining the 1865 Death Register (which explicitly names Moses as Daniel's father) with the fact that Daniel lived his entire life as a neighbor to William’s widow, the case is closed.

While a death register is technically a secondary source for parentage, we can trust this record because the information was provided by Daniel’s son-in-law, who would have had direct knowledge of the family history.

Daniel and William were brothers. And that means the Revolutionary service of Moses Epps belongs to our branch of the family tree, too.

Next Time: These spatial hues have helped us paint a fuller picture of the family's life in Halifax. In our next post, we trade the farm for the battlefield to explore the Continental Blue of Moses’ military service.

---

Series Tracker: Halifax Hues

• ✅ Post 1: The Faded Sketch — A Grandmother’s Roadmap
• ✅ Post 2: Layering the Pigment — The Widow’s Tax and Brotherly Bonds (current)
• [ ] Post 3: The Continental Blue — Moses Epps and the Revolution (Mar 11)
• [ ] Post 4: The Deep Roots of Indigo — Joshua Epps and the Colonial Foundation (Apr 8)
• [ ] Post 5: A Spectrum of Service — The Multi-Generational Military Web (May 13)

👉 View the full "Halifax Hues" Collection here

---

The Palette (Sources)

Moses Epps: 1820 Federal Census

• Details: Lists Moses Epps as head of household with a tally of young males that aligns with the ages of Daniel and William.
• Source: Fourth Census of the United States, 1820, Meadsville, Halifax County, Virginia; p. 61, image 78; NARA microfilm publication M33, roll 131; (https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/imageviewer/collections/7734/images/4433179_00078)

Lucy Epps: 1830 Federal Census

• Details: Moses and Daniel Epps are next to each other in the Census and six rows below is Lucy Epps.
• Source: Fifth Census of the United States, 1830, Halifax County, Virginia; p. 389, image 45; NARA microfilm publication M19, roll 192; (https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/search/collections/8058/records/858677)

William Epps & Lucy Cole: Marriage Record (1818)

• Details: Confirms the union that establishes Lucy as the widow found in the later census "clusters".
• Source: Virginia, Marriages, 1785–1940; (https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/search/collections/60214/records/4324420)

Daniel Epps: Death Register (1865)

• Details: Explicitly names Moses as his father; information provided by his son-in-law.
• Source: Virginia Deaths and Burials, 1853–1912; (https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/search/collections/62152/records/299523)

William Epps: Death (1826)

• Details: Records his early death, leading to Lucy being listed as "Head of Household" in 1830.
• Source: Virginia, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1652–1900, Will Books, vols. 13–14 (1823–1829), image 367; (https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/imageviewer/collections/62347/images/00367)